One of the characteristic of film noir is that there is usually
crimes involve, and when there’s a crime, it only takes couple characters to
write an effective story, the killer, victim a witness and the detective. We
already know that the killers in the story Double
Indemnity are Walter and Phyllis, and the victims are Mr. Nirdlinger, Lola,
Lola’s mother, Sachetti and the three kids murdered by our femme fatal. Murder
is a problem, often times a mystery and when there’s a problem, we look for solutions
or find answers.
In this story, Mr. Keyes assumes the role of a hard-boiled detective.
He works at the company for a long period of time and he knows everything about
it, he is someone who is hard to fool when it comes to the business because he
handled million of them and he’s aware that people are willing to kill for
money, not only that he is knowledgeable about the company but what makes him a
good detective is his personality “He’s big and fat and peevish, and on top of
that he’s a theorist, and it makes your head ache to be around him, but he’s
the best claim man on the coast, and he was the one I was afraid of” (56) He is
suitable on this role because he’s a very
curious guy like how Walter described him he is a theorist. He assumes
everything and wants to know everything, I don’t think it’s about the money or
the company anymore but he just want to uncover the truth behind Mr. Nirdlinger’s
death. He study and analyze every possible things that happened in the accident
and surprisingly got most of them right, He is certain that it is a murder and
not suicide; he knows how a criminal like Walter thinks. He looks beyond the
situation or facts that are presented. He even figured out that Mr. Nirdlinger
was never on the train, that he has to get rid of that guy Jackson, Keyes know
that no one would really recognize the Nirdlinger because it’s dark and he’s
wearing an eye glass, just like how Walter thought about it. Another quality of
Keyes that made him a detective type is that he is persistent ,the argument he
had with Mr. Norton whether it’s a suicide or not shows how hard headed he is “…All
right he wants to wait her out, make her sue-that suits me. He’s going to cover
the dead man, find out what he can about why he may be committed suicide. That
suits me; I am going to cover her” (67). Keyes truly play the detective role
well because he scared Walter and that’s the reason why he thought of killing
Phyllis, he knows Phyllis can turn him in, at that time Walter knows Keyes got
him.
Keyes character is pretty obvious,
we already know he is the major detective in this story but I also thought
Sachetti made his little share of curiosity. Unlike Keyes, Sachetti did
everything secretly, I think he did a pretty good job; he played it safe by
sleeping with his enemy. He’s investigating about the death of his father and the
murder of the 3 kids. He pretends that he likes Phyllis so he can be closer to
her but he didn’t expect that he will fall in love with Lola, I actually like that
idea, I think he is the only person who played Phyllis and manipulated her in some
way.
i totally agree that Mr. keyes was the hard-boiled detective his ways of trying to figure out the case of Mr. Nirdlinger was not going to by pass him. plus Mr. Keyes is very knowledgeable about the company he knows all the possible ways of trying to make it llok like it was accident but really is murder. and i didnt really think about Sachetti as the detective but you do make sense when you said how he was been secretly sleeping with his enemy just to investigate on his father murder n the 3 children. it was very clever of Sachetti to do that but great job!
ReplyDeleteI too believe that Keyes played the detective role in this novel. He was very sneaky and knew everything about everything. You gave some good facts that proved he was the detective type. He was never fooled when the idea of suicide came into the conversation. He always knew to follow his gut feeling, that's exactly what made him have knowledge about the situation that had occured. I really like how you included Sachetti as one of the detectives, I too believe he did the best to find out the truth about Phyllis. What did you think about Lola? Do you think maybe she played the detective type? Good job in identifying the other hard-boiled detective in the novel.
ReplyDeleteI thought that Keyes was definitely the detective type also. I thought that you very much nailed the question. I think you also did a good job by referencing the quotes from the book into you're entry. It made it more believable in the sense of Keyes being a detective. And I also like how you brought sachetti into the story also because he was very much like a detective in the book. Very good job.
ReplyDelete